Manchester United 1-2 Manchester City (Dec 10, 2017)
Premier League · · Regular Season - 16
This report covers goalscorers with minutes, bookings, both starting elevens, recent form for both sides and the head-to-head record for Manchester United 1-2 Manchester City.
Manchester United 1-2 Manchester City at Old Trafford
Managers: José Mourinho (Manchester United) · Guardiola (Manchester City)
This fixture is the Manchester Derby — see the full head-to-head record.
Match facts
- Venue: Old Trafford, Manchester
- Referee: Michael Oliver, England
- Round: Regular Season - 16
Record last updated .
Goals
Goalscorers with match minute.
- 43' David Silva for Manchester City
- 45+2' M. Rashford for Manchester United
- 54' N. Otamendi for Manchester City
Bookings
- 4' K. Walker — Yellow Card
- 36' Marcos Rojo — Yellow Card
- 63' M. Rashford — Yellow Card
- 73' David Silva — Yellow Card
- 79' Ander Herrera — Yellow Card
- 90' A. Young — Yellow Card
Lineups
Starting elevens and substitutes for both sides.
Manchester United — 4-2-3-1
Starting XI
- 1 · David de Gea (G)
- 5 · Marcos Rojo (D)
- 9 · R. Lukaku (F)
- 11 · A. Martial (M)
- 12 · C. Smalling (D)
- 14 · J. Lingard (M)
- 18 · A. Young (D)
- 19 · M. Rashford (M)
- 21 · Ander Herrera (M)
- 25 · A. Valencia (D)
- 31 · N. Matić (M)
Substitutes
- 2 · V. Lindelöf (D)
- 4 · P. Jones (D)
- 8 · Mata (M)
- 10 · Z. Ibrahimović (F)
- 20 · S. Romero (G)
- 23 · L. Shaw (D)
- 39 · S. McTominay (M)
Manchester City — 4-3-3
Starting XI
- 2 · K. Walker (D)
- 4 · Vincent Kompany (D)
- 7 · R. Sterling (F)
- 17 · K. De Bruyne (M)
- 18 · F. Delph (D)
- 19 · L. Sané (F)
- 21 · David Silva (M)
- 25 · Fernandinho (M)
- 30 · N. Otamendi (D)
- 31 · Ederson (G)
- 33 · Gabriel Jesus (F)
Substitutes
- 1 · Claudio Bravo (G)
- 3 · Danilo (D)
- 8 · İ. Gündoğan (M)
- 10 · Sergio Agüero (F)
- 15 · E. Mangala (D)
- 20 · B. Silva (M)
- 35 · Oleksandr Zinchenko (M)
Recent form (last 5)
Both teams' last five completed league matches — form string, points, and goals for/against.
- Manchester United: WWWWL · 12 pts from 5 · 12-5
- Manchester City: LWWWW · 12 pts from 5 · 9-5
Head-to-head
Most recent meetings between Manchester United and Manchester City.
- Manchester United 0-1 Manchester City · Sep 13, 2026
- Manchester United 2-0 Manchester City · Jan 17, 2026
- Manchester City 3-0 Manchester United · Sep 14, 2025
- Manchester United 0-0 Manchester City · Apr 6, 2025
- Manchester City 1-2 Manchester United · Dec 15, 2024
Other matches in Regular Season - 16
Premier League, Regular Season - 16.
- Liverpool 1-1 Everton — 10 Dec 2017