New York Red Bulls 1-1 New York City FC (Sep 23, 2021)
Major League Soccer · · Regular Season - 34
This report covers goalscorers with minutes, bookings, both starting elevens, recent form for both sides and the head-to-head record for New York Red Bulls 1-1 New York City FC.
New York Red Bulls 1-1 New York City FC at Red Bull Arena
Managers: G. Struber (New York Red Bulls) · R. Deila (New York City FC)
This fixture is the Hudson River Derby — see the full head-to-head record.
Match facts
- Venue: Red Bull Arena, Harrison, New Jersey
- Referee: I. Elfath
- Round: Regular Season - 34
Record last updated .
Goals
Goalscorers with match minute.
- 31' T. Castellanos for New York City FC (assist M. Moralez)
- 90+12' P. Klimala for New York Red Bulls — Penalty
Bookings
- 21' Alexander Callens — Yellow Card
- 44' A. Tinnerholm — Yellow Card
- 45' Sean Davis — Yellow Card
- 61' A. Reyes — Yellow Card
- 73' K. Parks — Red Card
- 80' P. Klimala — Yellow Card
- 82' K. Duncan — Yellow Card
- 84' C. Clark — Yellow Card
- 84' Maxime Chanot — Yellow Card
- 90+10' Maxime Chanot — Yellow Card
- 90+10' Maxime Chanot — Red Card
Lineups
Starting elevens and substitutes for both sides.
New York Red Bulls — 4-2-3-1
Starting XI
- 4 · A. Reyes (D)
- 7 · T. Edwards (D)
- 9 · Fábio Gomes (M)
- 10 · P. Klimala (F)
- 13 · Carlos Coronel (G)
- 15 · S. Nealis (D)
- 19 · W. Carmona (M)
- 21 · O. Fernandez (M)
- 23 · C. Cásseres (M)
- 27 · Sean Davis (M)
- 47 · J. Tolkin (D)
Substitutes
- 5 · A. Gutman (D)
- 6 · K. Duncan (D)
- 8 · F. Amaya (M)
- 16 · D. Yearwood (M)
- 17 · C. Harper (F)
- 18 · Ryan Meara (G)
- 37 · C. Clark (M)
- 74 · T. Barlow (F)
- 77 · D. Royer (M)
New York City FC — 3-4-2-1
Starting XI
- 1 · S. Johnson (G)
- 3 · A. Tinnerholm (M)
- 4 · Maxime Chanot (D)
- 6 · Alexander Callens (D)
- 7 · A. Morales (M)
- 10 · M. Moralez (F)
- 11 · T. Castellanos (F)
- 16 · J. Sands (D)
- 19 · J. Medina (F)
- 20 · G. Þórarinsson (M)
- 55 · K. Parks (M)
Substitutes
- 8 · Thiago Andrade (F)
- 12 · M. Amundsen (D)
- 13 · L. Barraza (G)
- 17 · Ismael Tajouri (F)
- 21 · A. Jasson (M)
- 23 · G. Zelalem (M)
- 26 · Nicolas Acevedo (M)
- 42 · S. Rodriguez (M)
- 43 · Talles Magno (F)
Recent form (last 5)
Both teams' last five completed league matches — form string, points, and goals for/against.
- New York Red Bulls: LLWLL · 3 pts from 5 · 7-13
- New York City FC: LWLWL · 6 pts from 5 · 9-9
Head-to-head
Most recent meetings between New York Red Bulls and New York City FC.
- New York City FC 0-1 New York Red Bulls · Sep 18, 2026
- New York Red Bulls 1-1 New York City FC · May 16, 2026
- New York Red Bulls 1-3 New York City FC · Apr 29, 2026
- New York Red Bulls 2-3 New York City FC · Sep 27, 2025
- New York City FC 2-0 New York Red Bulls · May 17, 2025